What is the First Step in a Brand Audit? Start With This Crucial Move

Do you know that only 60% of marketers say their brand is well-aligned with their company’s long-term goals? 

That leaves a considerable margin for misalignment, one that can quietly impact everything from customer perception to campaign performance.

A brand audit is the tool that brings those misalignments to light.

But before diving into visuals, messaging, or competitive analysis, there’s one foundational step that makes the rest of the process meaningful: setting your reason for doing the audit in the first place.

It sounds obvious, but you’d be surprised how many teams skip this. They jump straight into inspecting logos or nitpicking taglines, without asking what they’re trying to fix, measure, or improve.

Without clear goals, an audit becomes surface-level. With the proper focus, it becomes a strategic move.

At Ethos, we’ve helped hundreds of brands, from lean creative teams to sprawling enterprises, run smarter, more intentional audits.

We’ve seen the difference this first step makes.

Why Starting Right Matters

Defining objectives is where everything begins. It’s not just smart; it’s essential! 

Most of the time, what sets a successful audit apart from a scattered one is this: a clear, intentional starting point.

Without it, you risk measuring the wrong things, missing real issues, or walking away with shallow insights that don’t move your brand forward. At Ethos, we’ve seen teams skip this step and end up buried in data, unclear on what to do next.

Why This Step Is Non-Negotiable:

• It Defines Your Focus: Trying to fix everything at once? You’ll burn out your team and blur your results. Starting with clear goals helps narrow your audit to what matters most, whether it's visual consistency, messaging alignment, or improving internal workflows.
• It Helps You Ask the Right Questions: Without an objective, your audit becomes a matter of guesswork. When you know what you’re trying to solve or understand, your questions get sharper, and so do your answers.
• It keeps the Process Practical: With your goals in place, you're not just gathering data for the sake of it. Every step you take has a reason, and every insight can tie back to a tangible decision or next move.
• It Aligns Your Team: When everyone’s clear on the purpose of the audit, collaboration becomes smoother. Less confusion, fewer mixed signals, and better input from design, marketing, and leadership - everyone is pulling in the same direction.

How to Set the Right Scope and Goals

So, what’s the first step in a brand audit?

You need to define your scope and goals.

And once you’ve decided you’re ready to audit, the next decision is: how wide and deep do you go? 

If you set goals and scope too vague or too broad, things unravel fast. Know it right, and you’ll have a focused, impactful audit. However, if your goals and scope are too wide (or too vague), things can get messy fast.

1. Decide What You Want to Learn

• Trying to clear up brand confusion?
• Just went through a rebrand and need alignment?
• Or simply checking performance across platforms?

Whatever the reason, having that clarity up front makes the rest of the process way easier to navigate.

2. Define What’s In and What’s Out

It’s easy to want to look at everything, but being realistic about your focus helps. Maybe this round is all about digital. Or perhaps you also want to include items such as packaging, internal documents, or customer support touchpoints. Deciding that early on keeps the audit from becoming a headache.

3. Set Expectations

Some teams want a full brand transformation, hoping for a comprehensive brand transformation. While others just want a tidy-up.

Whichever one you are, spell it out. Getting straight to what you want out of it helps your team work smarter and turns audit findings into actionable decisions. 

• What to Document Before You Start

Before you dive into the audit, take stock of your brand’s current state. Get it all in one place. It saves time, creates consistency, and gives you a clear baseline.

Not sure where to begin? You might want to start by revisiting the core of your branding framework. If you're unsure what that includes, here’s a helpful breakdown on Brand Guidelines: What They Are and How to Create Them.

‍

Here’s what to round up:

• Your Brand Guidelines

Pull out your existing brand guidelines, if you have them. These might include your logo rules, color palettes, typography, and usage dos and don’ts. This will help you see how far things may have drifted from what was initially intended.

• Messaging Materials

Gather key messaging pieces, including website copy, social media bios, pitch decks, taglines, and any tone-of-voice documentation. This shows how your brand voice is coming through, or not. If it’s feeling inconsistent, it may be time to revisit your brand messaging and sharpen what you're trying to say.

• Design Assets

Round up logos, templates, marketing collateral, packaging files, anything visual that represents your brand. Even past campaigns can help you track visual evolution over time. If your visual identity isn’t telling the right story, this is the perfect moment to rethink your brand design from the ground up.

• Performance Data

If you have access to analytics, note how your brand is performing. Look at website traffic, social engagement, conversion rates, or customer feedback. These numbers can highlight gaps that you may overlook visually.

• Your Brand Purpose

Finally, revisit your brand’s mission, values, and positioning statements. These set the tone for your audit. If these core ideas have changed, or if your brand no longer reflects them, it’s a good sign that realignment is needed.

Wrap Up: Start with Purpose

Brands move fast. New campaigns. New team members. New tools, channels, and goals.

And in all that motion, it’s easy to forget to pause.

To ask: Is the foundation still solid?

This first step, setting your audit objective, is more than just a checkbox. It’s about how honest you’re ready to be with your brand.

Doing a brand audit isn’t about finding flaws. It’s about being bold enough to look. To face the places where your story has drifted. Where visuals fall flat.

Where tone no longer fits who you are. It’s about intention, clarity, and embracing your evolution. Because when you know why you’re auditing, the process stops feeling like pressure and starts unlocking possibility.

Next Step: Let’s Take That First Look Together

At Ethos, we’ve worked with brands at every stage, from startups finding their voice to legacy brands recalibrating after years of change.

The breakthrough? It always starts with purpose. That’s why our free 30-minute brand audit session isn’t a sales pitch.

It’s a real, focused conversation to help you define your direction and take that first strategic step.

Because of the future of your brand? It starts with what you choose to do next.

‍